You are here: Sri Vaishnava Home Page : Bhakti List : Archives : May 2000

Doctrine and the Drama

Ramanbil_at_aol.com
Date: Mon May 29 2000 - 07:13:54 PDT

Dear Bhagavatas:
I am overwhelmed by the encouraging responses from several readers on the 
series on "PrahlAda StOtram". 

With reference to the query of the BhAgavata on Sri MahAlakshmi (the 
inseparable Consort of the Lord) being portrayed in the StOtram as being 
"afraid" to approach the angry Lord, another BhAgavata had commented as 
follows:

"It was a very pertinent question of doctrine the BhAgavata raised and Sri. 
Anbil,
thank you Sir, for clarifying it equally well.

Yes, the purAna says that Mahalakshmi on seeing the terrible form of Her 
Lord's
avatAra recoiled from Him in fear. Commentators have added that 'thAyAr' was 
heard to even say, "This creature perhaps is not my Lord at all!".

Such portrayals of the purAni-c scene are entirely credible from a purely 
dramatic
point of view. But they should not be immediately confused with matters of 
some
doctrine or other... the doctrine of 'purushAkAram' in this case. Several 
'purAnic'
incidents do serve to illustrate doctrine; but that does not necessarily mean 
that
every doctrine has its affirmation in some 'purAnA'.

In the 'yuddha-kAndA' of the Ramayana we see Lord Rama savagely repudiate His
Consort Sita in the presence of all the world, as it were. Rama utters 
terrible
things, cruel things.... He even says He wished He never had to set eyes on 
Sita
again, ever.... etc. Now does all that mean Rama Himself negated the doctrine 
of
"purushAkAra"? That would be straining the credibility of both 'purAnA' and 
the
doctrine, isn't it?

We must be careful not to read too much meaning into 'purAni-c' incidents 
while using them to illustrate abstruse matters of doctrine or theology."
regards,
dAsan,
--------------------------
As indicated in my reply, in terms of the "leela" vouched by SwAmi DEsika and 
Bhagavad RAmAnuja (vide- "akhila bhuvana janma sthEma bhangAdi leelE") if  
the "acting in the drama of this AvatAra" of Lord Nrisimha and Sri 
MahAlakshmi has roused such reaction as to raise the query in the first 
place, it only goes to prove -

* The best Actress award goes to....Periya pirATTI ! 
and
* The best Actor award goes to....  Lord Nrisimha !  

Dasoham
Anbil Ramaswamy

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Calling all BOOK CLUBS! Join beMANY! And pay less each month on 
Long Distance. Our huge buying group gives you Long Distance rates 
which fall automatically!
http://click.egroups.com/1/4168/4/_/716111/_/959710401/
------------------------------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------------------
           - SrImate rAmAnujAya namaH -
To Post a message, send it to:   bhakti-list@eGroups.com
Visit http://www.ramanuja.org/sv/bhakti/ for more information